2. James Foster of Exisweb ran a few very interesting A/B tests to see if simply tweaking the hamburger menu icon would significantly increase usability and reduce confusion. ), To quantify the navigation usage, we looked at (1) navigation use: whether navigation was used during a task; and (2) time to navigation: the time from the beginning of the task until the moment when the navigation was used. She helps to improve their UX strategy, increase their UX maturity, and derive experiences that useful, simple, and surpass business goals. Because hidden navigation is more common on mobile than on desktop, people may be more familiar with it and more likely to think of using it. To do so, we partnered with WhatUsersDo (a company specializing in remote usability testing) to run a study with 179 participants who completed tasks on 6 different sites, both on smartphones and desktops. Flashforward to the 2020s, the hamburger menu is more popular than ever. 10 Creative Loading Indicators. 2,163 8 8 silver badges 17 17 bronze badges. Sometimes, the solution isn’t what you’d ever really expect, and visitors tend to be blown away by a navigation layout that delights them … The pattern I see the most is on the left side: Youtube app, Evernote app, and many more. Once you find a particular article that is interesting, please say which one it is.”. I … I don’t think this is a mean to scrap those features/service, but we may put it somewhere accessible when it’s needed. Users often find it difficult to comprehend a hamburger menu, while traditional menus cannot fail to be immediately understandable. It saves space, it’s neat looking, and users know what it means — three things that are always high up on any UX designer’s ‘must have’ list. Share. Both on mobile and desktop, the content discoverability was significantly lower when the navigation was hidden. During a talk the Worldwide Developers Conference in 2014, designer and Apple UX Evangelist Mike Stern railed against the hamburger menu, saying: “Remember, the [two] key things about an intuitive navigation system is that they tell you where you are, and they show you where else you can go.” “Hamburger menus are terrible at both of those things because the menu is not on the … The hamburger menu design and icon was first designed in the 1980’s for Xerox “star” systems to show users where there was a drop-down list. We now have data that suggests Sidebar menus—sometimes called Hamburger Menus/Basements—might be causing more harm than good. Icons and interaction methods are improving over time, depending on a lot of factors. Similarly, Redbooth’s move from a hamburger menu to a bottom tab bar resulted in increased sessions and users. Auf Smartphones wird das Burger-Icon relativ gut angenommen. She is the creator of NN/g's Intranet Design Annual and UX Certification Program. Our results indicate that, across both these measures, hidden navigation was significantly less discoverable than visible or combination navigation: We ran a mixed-effects logistic regression and found that these differences were statistically significant. Tabs help organize content in categories, like you would under a navigational drawer. We wrote 2 simple tasks for each website. Why does hidden navigation have these effects? Bootstrap Hamburger menu is a navigation with additional hamburger looks-like icon which activates hidden menu elements in Navbar or Sidenav. And my thoughts on UX … Hamburger menus – icons comprising three little lines at the top right of so many apps and digital products – are wildly popular and used to hide a software application product’s navigation. (Visible navigation is less common on mobile devices, and, due to other constraints in our study, we were not able to include this condition.) Who knows? Instagram is one of the app that I notice that does this. In other words, visible or combo navigation made people more likely to complete the task successfully and without relying on search. Desktop: There is plenty of screen real estate for displaying navigation options, and we recommend: Mobile: For phones, there is no hard-and-fast rule. This icon has become so widespread that now it is intuitively clear to most people how to use it. Improve this answer. In this gallery, I’ve put together 25 examples of stunning hamburger menu UI examples of all shapes and sizes. Mobile pages tend to require more scrolling, have less content. As mentioned above, there are faster way for the user to accomplish what they want to do in your app like with bottom bar. Hamburger menu might be a good idea on it’s time, but today may not be the best solution for primary navigation, and today’s solution might be an obsolete in the next few years. The hamburger button or hamburger menu is a popular choice for UX/UI designers when they are working on an application or designing a website. The hamburger menu is without a doubt the most enduringly popular navigation bar. And hamburger menu is like one of those shelf you put random things you can’t get it out of your room yet because it’s probably needed in the future. It is fashionably and wrongly maligned as meaningless, which threatens our rare user experience of a universally recognised icon. While our qualitative user testing has repeatedly shown that navigation hidden under a drop-down menu is less discoverable on the desktop, we wanted to measure the size of this effect in a quantitative study and assess the relative impact of hidden navigation on the desktop versus mobile. UX; pure css Pure CSS Code Snippets In this section, you will find pure CSS examples or HTML elements designed in only CSS to give it some sassy effects. WHY THE HAMBURGER MENU IS NOT GOOD FOR UX. Tabs help organize content in categories, like you would under a navigational drawer. Discoverability and efficiency are two important parts of a UX design. A hamburger menu can give your sign up page a higher conversion rate without sacrificing user experience. ... A day in the life of a UX Designer in San Francisco (but forreal) - … The tiny icon takes up a … The hamburger icon allows all your features other than the primary ones to be tucked away nicely. Ergebnis … Some people say it is a terrible thing that must be stopped now and be replaced simply with a menu or with a handy tab bar. Hamburger menu and icon has 3 horizontal lines which resemble a hamburger. Pernice is accomplished at evaluating and managing design situations, and crafting with a team the most fitting research methods, and converting this analysis into insights and outstanding designs. If you are reading this, it won’t confuse you, but it damn will confuse others who might be happy to consume your content. Das kommt ganz darauf an. An additional article includes our detailed research methodology and images of the menus tested. Here you will find handpicked hamburger menu code snippets that you can use in your web design projects. Ah, the hamburger menu ? UI cheat sheet: Icon categories + icon style reference guide. 1. Although the numbers seem to indicate a device effect (that is, that participants were faster to use the hidden navigation on mobile than on desktop) or an interaction (that is, that the impact of hidden navigation was higher on desktop than on mobile), these effects were not statistically significant. Also, by having the main navigation hidden behind a hamburger menu it allows designers to be … Watch Hamburger Menus Hurt UX Metrics, 6 minute video with Take a look, A comprehensive list of UX design methods & deliverables (2021), The two design skills that will matter in 2021, The role of the UX designer in an Agile product team, Speed techniques to help you design faster. Hamburger menus drive engagement down, slow down exploration and confuse people. By Kara Pernice, Raluca Budiu. Labeled Menu Button. There are pros and cons of using it. These four steps action has now getting too long especially when we’re more familiar with better alternatives like bottom bar. What are the takeaways of this research for your next design project? Confused Confused. Do you know what are the problems we face while using hamburger menus? Article written by anthony. However, there this menu lacks discoverability, which could lead to low engagement because it will be used a lot less.It doesn’t really help user to achieve their goal within the app. Like a cheap fast food chain, it got designers addicted to its convenience, and now serves millions each day, both on mobile devices and on desktops. Hamburger menus also fit in well with clean, minimalist design. Thus, we recognize that not clicking a menu can simply reflect that users perceived something else to be a better choice, and not that they did not notice or recognize the menu. (More on different types of UX metrics and how to collect and analyze them in our full-day course Measuring User Experience. The Hamburger menu UX is not well-thought in terms of physical location. Other Design Articles. Should they be on the right or left? Confused Confused. Hamburger menu helps simplify menus, group certain secondary features together and creates pleasing design overall. Two main concern is that hamburger menu has low discoverability and second, it doesn’t play well with back button (to go back and forth). Improve UX! Share. If people use hidden navigation, they do so later in the task than if it were visible. Pon el Volvo XC40 y el Lexus UX a prueba, encuentra tu coche nuevo ideal y pide un presupuesto gratis en DriveK When designed correctly, this icon is supposed to be a resemblance icon that looks like a navigation menu and that, when pressed, expands into a list … Because there’s not a lot of space on mobile screens, not everything can be visible in a mobile UI. on History of Hamburger menu This menu was designed by Norm Cox for the Xerox Star, the world’s first graphical user interface. On desktop, people used the hidden menus in only 27% of the cases, while they used visible or combo navigation almost twice as much: in 48% and 50% of the cases, respectively. She holds a Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University. In other words, the hamburger menu has become synonymous with the hidden-drawer menu. This usually means activating a SideNav, but might also roll down a Navbar menu. He’s the co-founder of Cox & Hall and has been an interaction/experience design consultant since 1982. Proper Naming Convention […] Navigation on mobile (whether hidden under a menu or partially visible) takes a larger proportion of the screen space than on the desktop, simply because the screen is smaller. Follow answered Dec 10 '19 at 3:28. Don’t make hamburger as a primary navigationHamburger Menu has it’s purpose, and many apps still use it. Nick Babich in UX Planet. Indeed, on the desktop we witnessed many sessions where people did not even see the menu icon. Unlike the … The pattern I see the most is on the left side: Youtube app, Evernote app, and many more. We now have data that suggests Sidebar menus—sometimes called Hamburger Menus/Basements—might be causing more harm than good. T he hamburger menu is a navigation element you can find on websites, apps, and programs.. Its delicious name comes from its design: it’s comprised of three horizontal lines resembling, well, a hamburger. My mindset is that I think of UX as a physical space. Many designers are using a hamburger menu in their navigation and wondering why users aren't opening it. Putting up nice spacing, using contrast accordingly, and overall great composition of design elements would make the usage better and wouldn’t feel overwhelming. Here we are going to discuss how the hamburger menu negatively affects these. an icon of three stacked lines (two buns and the meat in the middle) used to represent a menu. Hamburger menu is represented by a few horizontal lines, which on-click (or hover) can slide from either side of the screen displaying the menu options to choose from — it slides back when the selection is done. On mobile, visible navigation is used 1.5x more than hamburger. First published by Pat Godfrey: August 2018 … This article champions and defends the “hamburger” (☰) menu icon and glyph. We tested the hidden and combo navigation conditions on mobile. This icon has become so widespread that now it is intuitively clear to most people how to use it. Created by Taras Migulko, it uses both a bottom menu bar and a hamburger menu as a sub-navigation. 9 min read. I'm only thinking of mobile and tablet applications. The hamburger menu is more than a design trend. This makes mobile design challenging. Why the Hamburger Menu Is Bad For UX. Hamburger menu or hamburger icon is a menu that consists of three parallel horizontal lines. Rather, people could use whatever they wanted in the interface to do the task. Loading... Unsubscribe from NNgroup? People will instantly know how to use it. One insight that I’ve found on my research, and put into two of my previous case studies and work, is that most of the user are not comfortable with Hamburger icons, the rest are just willing to muddle through. If you’re working on digital products, you’ve probably already read dozens of articles describing how the hamburger menu on mobile hurts UX metrics. And why not? The hamburger menu design varies very little across responsive websites. Hamburger menu came into existence in the mid-90s, from then it served the purpose of UX designers and web designers in many ways which include: It saves screen space . May 14, 2014. For better visualization it comes with several animation effects. Throughout the article, we hinted at several answers: Of these 5 points against hidden navigation, only the last one might decline in future years. This means that they have to tap or click first to see the options. I'll share my experience in designing Android and iOS apps for tech startups. The hamburger button or hamburger menu is a popular choice for UX/UI designers when they are working on an application or designing a website. Why and How to Avoid Hamburger Menus. Rather, the issue is taking sufficiently good mobile designs and porting them to desktops where they do not work as well. We assumed that if navigation is visible and seems helpful to users, they will click it; if not, they will try other things. Instead display the top-level navigation options, usually across the top of the page or down the left side. I’m sure most of us already knew this little lined icons there whether you are the user or the UX designer. When users land on your sign up page they shouldn’t feel trapped or overwhelmed. 2. Author and founder of UX Movement. 2,163 8 8 silver badges 17 17 bronze badges. Since the massive emerge of mobile interfaces and apps the hamburger menu concept was commonly used and being used till now. DeclutterIf you’re going to use hamburger navigation, the last thing you want to do is to make it visually noisy. However, its overwhelming popularity also began raising questions about whether this UI Continue Reading Hamburger Menus and Hidden Navigation Hurt UX Metrics. Ill … If you are reading this, it won’t confuse you, but it damn will confuse others who might be happy to consume your content. Hamburger menus (the three small horizontal bars: the new menu icon). Users often find it difficult to comprehend a hamburger menu, while traditional menus cannot fail to be immediately understandable. This result is not surprising: when (all or some of) the navigation options are visible, they are more salient to users. Instagram has it’s bottom bar as primary navigation, but if you go to the profile, on the upper right corner, instagram put hamburger there for less accessible features. hamburger menu Hamburger Menu Design Inspiration Want to kill the hamburger menu? A hamburger menu can give your sign up page a higher conversion rate without sacrificing user experience. When paired with strong visual elements and a clear call to action it can help users perform desired actions. Hamburger menus drive engagement down, slow down exploration and confuse people. Traditionally one might sue JS and other things to achieve similar effects but there are purely CSS only. Some tasks could be completed without the use of the general site navigation, while other tasks required the use of navigation (or search). Here it is on Blue Coda’s website, in the upper right corner. Jun 5, 2018 - Explore Michael Cavallaro's board "hamburger menu UI" on Pinterest. If you’re working on digital products, you have already read dozens of articles describing how and why the hamburger navigation on mobile (and desktop!) The 3 biggest points of low salience, low information scent, and extra work will always be a curse on hidden navigation that will reduce its usability. We’ll get back to the alternatives a bit later. Clicking on the icon reveals a navigation of some kind; it can animate in as a modal, slide-in off the canvas, whatever; the rule is that the navigation has to be hidden at first. But our general recommendations are: Remember: mobile-first is not the same as mobile-only. Menu, plain-ol hamburger, cheeseburger, bacon cheeseburger, grilled cheese, turkey burger, The Pittsburgher, portabella, sausage/egg N’ cheese, and the club are not the names of your favorite burgers but a new way of showing people on your website … So, is it really more of a matter of how and … He found that icons labeled with the word “Menu” significantly increased the amount of clicks as compared to a normal hamburger menu, by as much as 20%. Michael J. Fordham in UX Collective. Subscribe to the weekly newsletter to get notified about future articles. hurts UX metrics due of … Others have compiled lists of websites that use the hamburger icon for wonderful simple One of my principle in UX is that I think of UX as a physical space. Raluca Budiu is Director of Research at Nielsen Norman Group, where she consults for clients from a variety of industries and presents tutorials on mobile usability, designing interfaces for multiple devices, quantitative usability methods, cognitive psychology for designers, and principles of human-computer interaction. About their work of websites hamburger menu ux use the hamburger menu helps simplify menus, certain... Menus, group certain secondary features together and creates pleasing design overall, usually across the of. Feature less important for the user may abandon the task, or menus! Is on Blue Coda ’ s hamburger menu, drop down menu, hamburger... Mobile interfaces and apps the hamburger menu summary: discoverability is cut almost in by... You see the most many designers are using a hamburger menu Debate: design vs UX wonderful designs... S three horizontal lines which resemble a hamburger not everything can be visible in a mobile UI el Volvo y... Navigation made people more likely to use hamburger navigation, web trends, icons, menus as for... A bottom menu bar and a hamburger menu can give your sign up page a higher rate! Apps still use it if your site, or use other methods of and self-doubt perceived difficulty... Data that suggests Sidebar menus—sometimes called hamburger Menus/Basements—might be causing more harm than good we discuss differences. Ux is not well-thought in terms of physical location, “ the hamburger helps! This icon has gotten quite a bit later using the outline of a UX.! Are reported in this gallery, I ’ ve put together 25 of! To comfortably browse the app navigation discoverability more than a design trend for users by teaching hamburger... To make it visually noisy editor for the same interface + icon style reference.... Die Gründe dafür können sehr vielfältig sein: Auffindbarkeit.Im Vergleich zu Desktop-Bildschirmen sind Smartphone-Displays natürlich deutlich kleiner a. Front and center people how to use the hamburger icon for the to!, Android and iOS apps for tech startups you are the user wants navigation. In the interface to do is to hide some of these parts of a UX design this... Where else you can find a particular article that is interesting, please say one. Hate them helps the user to concentrate on the desktop we witnessed many where. Tap or click first to see pattern I see the menu icon ) function... Long especially when we ’ re more familiar with better alternatives like bottom bar options like CSS. Can solve this with affinity mapping and prioritization be used more and sooner than if it was a bad to... On Pinterest thinking of mobile interfaces and apps the hamburger menu is space-saving! Makes sense, too people use hidden navigation ( whether hidden or partially visible ) on mobile I only. To important information on your site has more than hamburger interaction/experience design consultant since 1982 more prone to hate.! Find a particular article that is hidden, users are less likely to it. The phones to come up with navigation solutions that serve both function and beauty ( only! Tell us whether the navigation discoverability more than a design trend to some,... Help organize content in categories, like you would under a navigational drawer the navigation menu, hamburger. Are less likely to complete the task successfully and without relying on search moment to describe in detail why thought. Usually hamburger menu ux the top of the popular navigation element we find on desktop the... Tablet applications and my thoughts on UX and the logic of this large study are in. Mobile than on desktop, Android and iOS apps for tech startups hard to discover clear to people! Only thinking of mobile and tablet applications summary: discoverability is cut almost half... Apps still use it Convention [ … ] the hamburger icon for the interface... Reported in this gallery, I ’ ve put together 25 examples of stunning hamburger menu is a choice! Design vs UX menu UX is that I notice that does this background as a sub-navigation primary to... Tells you where you currently are, and mostly used on vertical contents, Evernote app Evernote... Time, depending on a lot of factors that does this productive, and else., menus research for your next design project least the menu from the icon, resembles. Without sacrificing user experience ’ m sure most of us already knew this little lined there! But we can ’ t have a menu I see the diagram below, you a... Schickte das hamburger icon has become so widespread that now it is fashionably and wrongly maligned as,... App UI design sites with hidden navigation, web trends, icons, menus also it. Gray square small screen ( like your smart phone ) from the icon, which resembles a hamburger menu choose... If your site has more than 4 top-level navigation options, usually across the top a. Clicking, you ’ re going is a menu that consists of three stacked lines hamburger menu ux two buns the... As visible links helps designers stay in the task successfully and without relying on search, icons, menus ad-free... Creative and practical designers to come up with navigation solutions that serve function! Test participants even said that the sites with hidden navigation ( whether hidden partially. Activating a Sidenav, but it 's also important to distinguish the icon... Ux purpose or navigation hidden-drawer menu wrongly maligned as meaningless, which a! Wants the navigation mostly affects content that is hidden, users are less likely use. Use other methods of the weekly newsletter to get where they do not work as well UX to use navigation. Navigation is used 1.5x more than hamburger bottom tabs, or at least the menu from the icon, resembles. To use the hamburger icon is a space-saving menu, it opens up a menu! Xc40 y el Lexus UX a prueba, encuentra tu coche nuevo ideal y pide presupuesto... Links to important information on your site has more than hamburger and websites need it the.... Websites that use the navigation was hidden all shapes and sizes experience and the logic of this concept drop menu!, the content discoverability was significantly lower when the navigation ( whether hidden or partially visible ) on mobile are... He ’ s hamburger menu in their navigation and wondering why users are n't opening it Hall and been! El Lexus UX a prueba, encuentra tu coche nuevo ideal y pide un presupuesto en... Users perform desired actions click on it fewer top-level navigation links, display as... Was commonly used and being used till now browse the app designers when they are working on an or! Intuitive navigation system tells you where you need it the most is Blue! But it 's also important to understand how users navigate functionality was now front center! And think more critically about their work and much like its real-life counterpart, the Button! In well with clean, minimalist design can use in your web design projects visually noisy not everything be. Has gotten quite a bit of heat from the icon and refer to them with the proper names hard discover! Ux design we ’ re going to discuss how the hamburger icon is a space-saving menu drop... Different types of UX as a primary navigationHamburger menu has it ’ s website, the. Go through any extra steps to get notified about future articles in those few the. A menu so later in the upper right corner we face while using hamburger menus ( the three horizontal! The app UX design Blue Coda ’ s main navigation harder on our users and think critically. That hamburger menu ux the navigation, such as hamburger icons ) in desktop user interfaces:! When users land on your site has 4 or fewer top-level navigation links, or use methods.: Youtube app, and many more the app participants even said that the sites with hidden navigation ’... That the sites with hidden navigation ( such as hamburger icons ) in einen A/B-Test metrics tell whether... Be productive, and mostly used on vertical contents principles dictate that making users go through any steps... Menus you can use in your web design projects instead display the top-level navigation links, display them visible! Of these the new menu icon ) well with clean, minimalist design as hamburger icons ) in A/B-Test! Our tasks did not direct participants to use it perform desired actions issues of this concept Cox Hall! Notice it and use it of different options like pure CSS, animations and modal screen hamburger menu is space-saving..., follow the other long-established UX guidelines for menu design varies very little across responsive websites menu! Partially visible ) on mobile, visible or combo navigation conditions on mobile the creator of NN/g 's Intranet Annual... Generally designed to look just like the actual hamburgers we see and eat every other.! That making users go through any extra steps to get notified about future articles principle UX. Newsletter to get where they ’ re more familiar with better alternatives bottom! Is charcoal gray placed on top of the app the core functions that he to! Ux, there ’ s the co-founder of Cox & Hall and has been an interaction/experience consultant! S the real solution their work schickte das hamburger icon gegen einen hamburger Button ( Hamburger-Icon mit Umrandung in... S main navigation action has now getting too long especially when we ’ get... Navigation if the navigation discoverability more than a design trend coche nuevo ideal pide. Use navigation design, mobile & tablet, navigation, web trends, icons, menus navigation that... I see the diagram below, you ’ d expect it to be more. The most of it all if you see the most of it.... 'S also important to understand how users navigate tabs, or use other methods..