What is a reason that the Missouri Compromise did not have lasting effects? The reason that the Constitution … Social Studies. It is the birth day of National Independence, and of political freedom. The Constitution may be right, the Government is wrong. The Republican Party could not secure the votes to support universal suffrage. Like all great thinkers, Douglass was a complicated man whose position evolved throughout his lifetime. Douglass believed that the Constitution of the United States should be protected and respected but he certainly thought that slavery was an abomination and should be stopped. . He was also a believer in dialogue and in making alliances across racial and ideological divides, as well as in the liberal values of the U.S. Constitution . If the Government has been governed by mean, sordid, and wicked passions, it does not follow that the Constitution is mean, sordid, and wicked. Why does Douglass state that “education and slavery were incompatible with each other”? But to Douglass with slavery still not over there was no need for the Declaration of Independence. Since slaves are not free, Douglass believes this demonstrates that slavery is not supported by the constitution. By acknowledging the validity of the Constitution, Douglass inserted himself into a new dialogue and demonstrated he was a participant in American society rather than an agitator. The United States Constitution specifically permitted slavery. In 1851 Douglass began publicly discussing his view that the Constitution, especially in the context of federal jurisdiction, could be used to support emancipation. Rather, he believed that freedom allowed individuals to reach their full capabilities. Douglass also says that if the residents of America believe that slaves are "men",: 342 they should be treated as such. To be an American man meant that you had the right to vote and hold office. The Constitution would become the lens through which he would advocate for the freedom and natural rights of all people, African Americans and women. The highest order of genius is as dependent as is the lowest.” Only after acknowledging that human beings are sub-ordinate within the cosmos and co-ordinate with one another does Douglass begin his celebrated tribute to self-made men. What kinds of knowledge about themselves does he believe are kept from slaves, and why does he believe this is important. Douglass was an imposing figure, both physically and intellectually. When an audience member objected to his claim citing Black women, Douglass countered, arguing that Black women were targeted because of their race rather than their gender.4 He eventually attempted to compromise during the meeting by submitting a resolution which agreed to welcome the Fifteenth Amendment while committing to efforts to gain rights without regards to gender.5 His proposal, however, was ignored. manifest destiny . Follow her on Twitter @NoelleTrentPhD. The passage continues: “I believe in individuality, but individuals are, to the mass, like waves to the ocean. Classroom is the educational resource for people of all ages. From 1788 until 1860, only two opponents of slavery, John Adams and John Quincy Adams, held the nation's highest office, and for only a total of eight years. Historians now believe that Douglass had an affair for over twenty years, from 1856 to 1881, with Ottilie Assing, a German journalist and political radical. Upon emancipation, Black men wanted those same rights and privileges. Yet even at the height of the violence and disenfranchisement of Black people, Douglass found no fault with the Constitution. Douglass also wants the nation to re-evaluate what the founding fathers wrote into the constitution and I think it is key that he mentioned that nothing about slavery is mentioned in the constitution and therefore to support what it stands for would be to not support slavery. And first a word about the question. Frederick Douglass believed the United States Constitution was itself an anti-slavery document, a view that differed sharply from that of some abolitionists in the mid-19th century. The United States Constitution specifically permitted slavery. Douglass was enslaved in Maryland until escaping to New York City in 1838. Activists like William Lloyd Garrison that it was and that the United States required a fundamental rethinking of its charter. The debate about the Amendment fractured many of Douglass’s long-term relationships with his women’s rights allies. He further says, the constitution, in its words, is plain and intelligible, and is meant for the home-bred, unsophisticated understandings of … In the aftermath of the Civil War, Douglass was realistic rather than quixotic about the realities facing African Americans. Douglass was a firm believer in the equality of all peoples, be they white, black, female, Native American, or Chinese immigrants. Almost immediately, he participated in abolitionist activities. Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton started a weekly newspaper, The Revolution, to articulate their women’s rights agenda. It was about demonstrating that Black people were human. 1 Frederick Douglass, “The Constitution of the United States: Is it Pro-Slavery or Anti-Slavery?”(Halifax: NS: T. and W. Birtwhistle, 1860). The complicated aspect of this legacy came after the Civil War during the controversy over the Fifteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Editorials in The Revolution articulated concern over the inclusion of Black men in an oppressive patriarchal regime resulting in: violence, conquest, disease, and death; White women dominated by inferior Black men; and increased hostility from lower class men toward women. The currency wasn't stable; there were lots of debts. 1. Douglass came to believe that documents recording the debates of the framers during the composition of the Constitution, as well as a straight reading of both that document and the Declaration of Independence proved the framers did not intend to preserve the institution of slavery. https://wjmi.blogspot.com/2014/03/frederick-douglass-on-constitution-and.html Frederick Douglass' July 4th Oration, "the Constitution is a GLORIOUS LIBERTY DOCUMENT." Stanton and Anthony collected 400,000 signatures in support of the Thirteenth Amendment in 1863, and along with Douglass were ardent supporters of universal suffrage in the aftermath of the war. It does not often happen to a nation to raise, at one time, such a number of truly great men. Under his new thought, Douglass stated that recent presidential administrations had led the government away from its founding ideals. A former disciple now attacked the positions of his mentor—positions Douglass himself had defended in public for over a decade—and this generated tension between the two men. . It solved nothing. The Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments did not protect African Americans from poverty, violence, or disenfranchisement. Hopefully, community members will take time to reflect with family and friends on the distances between our everyday actions and our highest ideals. Douglass’s constantly reconsidered his ideas about the Constitution as the realities of Black life, especially in the South, changed. [11] Yes. Initially, Douglass found himself at odds with his fellow Garrisonian abolitionists; later his support of the Fifteenth Amendment and Black male suffrage was opposed by some of his White female allies. However, the recent amendments created a new paradigm for Douglass. In the remainder of Chapter Ten, Douglass gives numerous examples of his courage: intellectual, emotional, spiritual and physical. "Though he does say that the Constitution, for instance, is still a 'glorious liberty document.' Frederick Douglass was inducted into the AERA as one of its three vice presidents at the organization’s first meeting in May 1866. Douglass, a longtime member, announced that under this new policy his paper The North Star was ineligible for their endorsement. A quick look at the presidency underscored their view. He continued to hold the Constitution in high reverence, stating that his life’s work had been to see the principles of liberty and humanity expressed in the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence fully realized without regard to race, gender, or religion. Frederick Douglass did not always believe the Constitution was an anti-slavery document. He was also a believer in dialogue and in making alliances across racial and ideological divides, as well as in the liberal values of the U.S. Constitution. She received a Bachelor of Science degree in journalism from Emerson College. NO! Douglass publicly changed his stance on the Constitution in the spring of 1851. Suffrage placed White men at the top of the American social hierarchy allowing them to influence the workings of American democracy. 215.409.6600 The Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States presented the first threat to the durability of the American Equal Rights Association. 1 The Constitution of the United States: Is It Pro-Slavery or Anti-Slavery? Sign up to get the latest posts and updates. “Now,” Douglass continues, “take the Constitution according to its plain reading, and I defy the presentation of a single pro-slavery clause in it. Why does Douglass believe that the continued existence of slavery tarnishes the principles expressed in the Declaration of Independence? Despite the hope engendered by the passage of the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery following the war, Douglass remained cautious, observing: “Verily, the work does … Women’s rights activists like Anthony and Stanton were appalled by the shift in the suffrage agenda. I proceed to the discussion. Frederick Douglass in his narrative, “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass,” discusses the role of religion, Christianity in particular, which was written in literature known as the bible had two versions: true Christianity and the white Christianity that helped in strengthening slavery. Douglass was a firm believer in the equality of all peoples, be they white, black, female, Native American, or Chinese immigrants. She holds a doctorate in American history for Howard University, and is currently expanding her dissertation Frederick Douglass and the Making of American Exceptionalism into a book. The Constitution did not permit slavery. Each author’s posts reflect their own views and not necessarily those of the African American Intellectual History Society Inc. AAIHS welcomes comments on and vigorous discussion about our posts. To answer this question, ... We have been miseducated by modern polling to believe that this is a simple question, but there is much evidence, both historical and contemporary, to suggest that majorities are often ephemeral. Douglass also wants the nation to re-evaluate what the founding fathers wrote into the constitution and I think it is key that he mentioned that nothing about slavery is mentioned in the constitution and therefore to support what it stands for would be to not support slavery. But Assing was more than a lover; she was Douglass' intellectual partner. Once he committed to his belief in the Constitution as a valid document, he used it as a tool in his arsenal to advocate for the freedom, and later the civil rights of African Americans and women. The American government and the American Constitution are spoken of in a manner which would naturally lead the hearer to believe that the one is identical with the other, when the truth is they are as distinct in character as is a ship and a compass. Douglass does not shy away from declaring his own devotion to Christianity and does not fail to distinguish his faith from that of slaveholders. By becoming a political abolitionist, Douglass challenged the country to reconsider who was a citizen and entitled to protection under the Constitution. The women’s rights movement in the United States had been strongly linked with the abolition movement. Noelle Trent is the Director of Interpretation, Collections & Education at the National Civil Rights Museum in Memphis, Tennessee. A. For Black men, this right was particularly important because it allowed them to protect their communities and families and insure their interests were represented in the American government. By the early 1850s, however, Douglass, under the influence of Gerrit Smith, abandoned the position that the U.S. Constitution is proslavery. Enfranchisement meant that Black men could contribute to American society by voting and holding office, but more importantly receive the economic benefits of American society. In 1841 he met Garrison, who would become his mentor. It was on this day that Douglass wrote in a … the duty of every American citizen to use the Constitution, Douglass challenged the country to reconsider who was a citizen, Black men wanted those same rights and privileges, ardent supporters of universal suffrage in the aftermath of the war, not secure the votes to support universal suffrage, did not protect African Americans from poverty, violence, or disenfranchisement, without the benefits of protection by law enforcement, On the Life of Black Abolitionist Anna Murray Douglass, Women’s Experiences during the American Civil War, Mass Incarceration and the Metaphor of Slavery, Blog Announcement: New Editors and Bloggers, Online Roundtable: Robert T. Chase’s ‘We Are Not Slaves’, Medicalizing Black Military Service in an Age of Global Imperialism. The debate about suffrage for Black men severed ties between White suffragists and Black activists including Douglass. In the decades after the war, he was the most influential African American leader in the nation. Women’s rights activists like Susan B. Anthony, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and Lucy Stone were also abolitionists. English. Douglass also argued that the framers, who in Article 1 of the Constitution included of a 20-year limit on the importation of African slaves, intended the practice of slavery to end after that date. Civil War Trust: The Road to Emancipation, National Archives: Garrison's Constitution, Frederick Douglass: The Constitution and Slavery, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Frederick Douglass. Independence Mall. Yet Douglass’ rebuke to both sides presents the way forward: Douglass does not pander to either, but is instead honest and challenges others to the same honesty. It was therefore the duty of every American citizen to use the Constitution and political processes at their disposal to bring the country in line with its founding intent. However, while Garrison believed the Founding Fathers intentionally preserved the institution of slavery in the Constitution, Douglass eventually came to the opinion that the framers intended the U.S. Constitution to be an evolving document that could be wielded as a weapon against slavery. Douglass, however, had long been recognized as a women’s rights man. How does Douglass maintain the order and coherence of the first sentence of this paragraph? In other writings and speeches, Douglass also praised the antislavery potential of the Constitution (which, I think, he in some respects overstated). Tanya Roberts has died after early, inaccurate death report. 1. The two spent much time together, reading everything from Shakespeare to Marx. Douglass, influenced by Garrison’s opinions regarding the Constitution, had developed a negative view of the Law of the land. New, more contagious COVID strain identified in 4 states That sentiment was endorsed by his fellow abolitionist, Wendell Phillips; Ohio Senator Benjamin Wade; and African American activist John Mercer Langston. An examination of Douglas’ thoughts on the Constitution needs the context of his lifelong competition with Abraham Lincoln, and the meteoric trajectory of his career. manifest destiny . It is a slander upon their memory, at least, so I believe. (Douglass believes that a person can't both be a Christian and a slave owner.). Douglass drew on the tradition of natural law in his argument against slavery. Douglass expands upon the basic point in the Smith letter in his celebrated speech on the Constitution at Glasgow in 1860. Frederick Douglass after reading the constitution he said, . I will state it. Christianity is of importance in Douglass's speech. What did he believe prevented Americans from living up to the Constitution? Why does the Constitution place so many obstacles in the way of majority rule? What the Constitution means to Frederick Douglass. Social Studies. Before Hamilton took charge of the country, the financial situation was horrible. See disclaimer. He fought for enfranchisement for Black men, but insisted that once that right was acquired, Black men could help in the push for women’s suffrage.1. *This post is part of our online forum on the life of Frederick Douglass. What did he believe prevented Americans from living up to the Constitution? Douglass was also a big believer in private property rights and the right of people to keep what they earn, because those things also are crucial to self-reliance. They also explore Douglass’ views of the Declaration of Independence—including that the principles expressed in the Declaration are eternal, but America does not live up to them in practice—as well as the Constitution. This allowed him to argue--contrary to everything that most Americans at the time believed and that most historians today believe--that the three-fifths clause punished, rather than rewarded, the South for slavery. Enfranchised citizenship was of the utmost importance to Black people. Douglass wanted to make it clear: this was an emergency. 525 Arch Street. Providing Black men suffrage would be a social recognition of them as men and, according to nineteenth century cultural mores, also legitimize them as capable of being a moral force in society. True Christians, according to Douglass, should not stand idly by while the rights and liberty of others are stripped away. Despite the conflict with friends and allies, he would continue to view the Constitution as the ideal to which the country had yet to fulfill. In 1866, they formed the American Equal Rights Association. The only mention of bills in Article I is in reference to prohibiting states from issuing "bills of credit." The one may point right and the other steer wrong. June 25, 2015 The 4th of July will soon be upon us in and around Baltimore, Charleston, and Ferguson – and all across the United States. Douglass was invoking a principle of constitutional interpretation that holds that the text itself is all that matters, that the intentions of the framers are irrelevant. In his views on slavery and the Constitution, how does Douglass differ from his fellow abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison (“On the Constitution and the Union” ) and from Abraham Lincoln (Speech on the Repeal of the Missouri Compromise and First Inaugural Address )? © 2020 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, All Rights Reserved. Douglas escaped north to freedom in 1838. The divergence of Douglass’ opinion from that of Garrison ended their friendship. Douglass, for example, believed the “We the people” opening of the preamble of the Constitution encompassed African-Americans -- meaning they were similarly guaranteed to the “life, liberty and pursuit of happiness” outlined in the Declaration of Independence. The American Anti-Slavery Society established a new policy denouncing any paper that opposed the organization’s belief in the Constitution as a pro-slavery document at its 1851 annual meeting. Frederick Douglass (1818–1895) was an escaped slave who joined William Lloyd Garrison as an abolition speaker and journalist. Celebrities face backlash for jet-setting during pandemic. Frederick Douglass' case for an anti-slavery Constitution. Douglass’s constantly reconsidered his ideas about the Constitution as the realities of Black life, especially in the South, changed. Douglass believed that the Constitution of the United States should be protected and respected but he certainly thought that slavery was an abomination and should be stopped. What, then, is the question? He would later characterize the status of Black southerners as “in law free, in fact slave; in law a citizen, in fact an alien; in law a voter, in fact disenfranchised…It [government] imposes upon him all the burdens of citizenship and withholds from him all its benefits.” Black people were working, paying taxes, defending the country, and upholding the laws and customs of society without the benefits of protection by law enforcement, enfranchisement, and the government working to insure life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Yes. The great debate among abolitionists in the nineteenth century was whether or not slavery was a pro-slavery document. Citizenship recognized their native-born status and guaranteed them access to the rights and privileges associated with U.S. birth. https://wjmi.blogspot.com/2014/03/frederick-douglass-on-constitution-and.html Frederick Douglass March 26, 1860 A Speech Delivered in Glasgow, Scotland …I proceed to the discussion. As Philip Foner has argued, the transition to political abolitionism made Douglass more moderate and palatable to the masses. and believe that the way to abolish slavery in America is to vote such men into power as well use their powers for the abolition of slavery. Douglass’s shift on the Constitution would inform the rest of his career. He soon became a prominent and successful orator and writer. A chart is one thing, the course of the vessel is another. To him, the fortuitous events of his early life could not be random; rather, they were ordained by a benevolent divine power. Donald Trump, Republican nominee for president, does not believe in the United States Constitution.. That’s a strong statement, but it’s increasingly clear that it’s true. The United States Constitution has a powerful and enduring place in the career of Frederick Douglass. After the Dred Scott decision, Frederick Douglass said he sought to have Americans live up to the principles of the Constitution. - 4th of July. He also changed his mind about Garrison’s call to dissolve the Union. Not only does the Constitution not prohibit Joe D. Scrote from producing his own currency called Scrote Bux (it only comes in denominations of two), it also doesn't grant the U.S. government the right to produce paper money at all. Frederick Douglass after reading the constitution he said, . The Constitution as Pro-Slavery. Another argument against Douglass’ claim that slavery is unamerican is the fact that within the Constitution, black people are called “three-fifths” (U.S Constitution, Section I) of a person. Why did Alexander Hamilton believe that the national bank was constitutional? The Constitution was proslavery, the national government was controlled by slaveowners, and politics was a waste of time. And first a word about the question. Ashley Portero has been covering state and national politics since 2011. For Douglass, there was something greater at stake than simply obtaining the right to vote for Black men. After the Dred Scott decision, Frederick Douglass said he sought to have Americans live up to the principles of the Constitution. Frederick Douglass's friends in the abolitionist movement were all extremely faithful Christians, but, in The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Douglass has some really harsh criticisms for slave owners who claim to be Christians. He employs parallelism, a type of organization in which a writer places similar ideas in a similar structure. The political reform agenda in Washington centered on reforms for newly freed Black people, and a universal suffrage amendment was removed in favor of suffrage for African American men. Douglas had constitutional thoughts, but these thoughts derived more from politics rather than legal training, morality or philosophy. Upon emancipation, universal suffrage was the next goal on the reform agenda especially among the abolitionists and women’s rights groups. New book highlights Frederick Douglass’s embrace of the “self-made man” Posted on February 12, 2018. He believed that the aftermath of the Civil War was the time to advocate for Black citizenship and suffrage. African American Intellectual History Society. How does Douglass use religious references to bolster his claims, such as in the phrase "from the tomb of slavery, to the heaven of freedom"? Philadelphia, PA 19106. The argument that the Constitution is racist suffers from one fatal flaw: the concept of race does not exist in the Constitution. Does Douglass believe that the United States Constitution is a pro-slavery or an anti-slavery document? Others, like Gerrit Smith and Frederick Douglass argued the opposite. He would later characterize the status of Black southerners as “in law free, in fact slave; in law a citizen, in fact an alien; in law a voter, in fact disenfranchised…It [government] imposes upon him all the burdens of citizenship and withholds from him all its benefits.” In a speech before the Scottish Anti-Slavery Society in Glasgow, Scotland on March 26, 1860, Frederick Douglass outlines his views on the American Constitution. When it became clear that the Fourteenth Amendment would exclude a suffrage component, the focus of the Fifteenth Amendment became suffrage. The tension between the burden and benefits of citizenship characterized the ongoing battle for civil rights in the United States. Regardless of how old we are, we never stop learning. Much will be gained at the outset if we fully and clearly understand the real question under discussion. Her work has appeared in "The Boston Globe," "The Boston Business Journal" and the "International Business Times." on Frederick Douglass and the United States Constitution, Submit a Guest Post or Roundtable Proposal. Frederick Douglass believed the United States Constitution was itself an anti-slavery document, a view that differed sharply from that of some abolitionists in the mid-19th century. Whether you’re studying times tables or applying to college, Classroom has the answers. Stand idly by while the rights and privileges Constitution may be right, the focus of the Fifteenth was. Their women ’ s rights groups that there will be disagreement but that. The emancipation of the United States required a fundamental rethinking of its charter among abolitionists... Database for the Declaration of Independence Garrison believed the entire structure of the States... T until he was the time to reflect with family and friends on the Constitution spirited..., Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments did not have lasting effects * this is. After early, inaccurate death report supported by the shift in the aftermath the! Escaped slave who joined William Lloyd Garrison as an abolition speaker and journalist be Christian. South, changed intellectual partner the next goal on the reform agenda especially among the abolitionists and women ’ rights... Became suffrage had led the Government is wrong grew up believing the Constitution the... They formed the American founding was Feb. 9, 1849 the South,.... Announced that under this New policy his paper the North Star was ineligible for their endorsement York in. That under this New policy his paper the North Star was ineligible for their endorsement,... Realities facing African Americans from poverty, violence, or disenfranchisement mean spirited comments will not be and! That “ Education and slavery were incompatible with each other ” spring of 1851 in which a writer similar! Declaration what does douglass believe about the constitution? Independence in 1866, they formed the American social hierarchy allowing them influence... Still a 'glorious liberty document. has died after early, inaccurate death.... Garrison, who would become his mentor of Garrison ended their friendship fractured many of Douglass ’ s rights what does douglass believe about the constitution?... Free and started to read that he became a prominent and successful orator and.. The abolitionists and women ’ s rights movement in the nation that the “ of. Tarnishes the principles of the Civil War, he believed that the Constitution who! The Word Net lexical database for the oppression of slaves the vessel is another given by,! A similar structure recent Amendments created a New paradigm for Douglass had led the away... The Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Lucy Stone were also abolitionists Constitution of the United States: is it or..., so I believe in individuality, but these thoughts derived more from politics rather than quixotic about Constitution! Ineligible for their endorsement others are stripped away, Tennessee about demonstrating that people... Was enslaved in Maryland until escaping to New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 256,. Granting African American activist John Mercer Langston let me state what is not the question he met what does douglass believe about the constitution?. For by God, and Fifteenth Amendments did not always believe the Constitution as the realities facing African.. Politics rather than quixotic about the realities facing African Americans there will be disagreement but ask that you Civil. Lots of debts you had the right to vote for Black men severed ties between White and... For Douglass and hold office easing the way of what does douglass believe about the constitution? rule by James A.,. Received a Bachelor of Science degree in journalism from Emerson College Journal '' and the steer. Should not stand idly by while the rights and privileges associated with birth... Guest post or Roundtable Proposal free and started to read that he intended all in...